Give Ocha Andrei's Ring. It is the correct memento for the amnesia ritual. The cleaver and pendant are wrong.
- Recommended
- Give Ocha Andrei's Ring. It is the correct memento for the ritual, but it does not save Andrei.
- Immediate impact
- The ring makes Ocha's spell work. The cleaver or pendant makes the ritual fail and starts a fight.
Correct answer
Give Ocha Andrei's Ring. It is the correct memento for the amnesia ritual. The cleaver and pendant are wrong.
With the ring, Ocha's spell works and Andrei later kills himself by striking his head against a wall. If Coen hands over the cleaver or pendant, the ritual fails and Coen and Ocha must fight Andrei. The wrong choice therefore reaches the same broad “Andrei dies” state as attacking him directly, but changes how it happens and limits Ocha's later options.
All three objects are in the upper room of Andrei's butcher shop. Entering through the balcony at night fits the walkthrough route.
Sources
Follow-up effects
The quest later asks Coen to advise Ocha about her future. Her available outcomes depend partly on whether Andrei died through the working spell or in combat. The quest reward is the Broad Swing Swordmastery manual across the documented branches.
This guide draws on the sources listed in the article. Uncertain claims and limits are explained in the text.